Debate of the Week

Are we losing more than words?

Linguists say the world’s minority languages are going through a mass extinction event. This may make communication easier. But what else is lost?

Imagine looking at someone. Both of you want to speak but are afraid to start. This is called mamihlapinatapai, in the South American language of Yamana. The point of International Mother Language Day, is to celebrate world’s many languages. But last Wednesday, the last speaker of Yamana died.

Many experts say language shapes how we think. Yamana tells us about the landscape, wildlife and culture of the region. And for many people, language is part of who they are.

This is also about the future, says expert David Harrison. “No culture has a monopoly on human genius, and we never know where the next brilliant idea may come from.”

Calderón’s children were the first generation to grow up speaking Spanish, in order to go to school and find work. And some people think we would be better with just one world language.

According to the Bible, languages were created when God punished humans for building the Tower of Babel. Today, people use common languages for culture, business and politics. Experts have even designed universal languages, like Esperanto.

English has more words than any other language, but it is not more advanced. Most native languages “have incredibly complex grammatical systems”, says expert Mark Turin.

Now it is a race against time to record these languages before the last speaker dies. There is no word for goodbye in Cherokee, only: “I will see you again.” With fewer than 2,000 speakers, it too is endangered. For some, its fate is inevitable. But others say these languages must survive.

WHAT’S YOUR TAKE?

Are we losing more than words?

Yes

Languages are worlds, they show something special about a culture and its people. Each language makes the world richer.

No

Languages are tools for communication. If we all spoke the same tongue, there would be more understanding and less conflict.

Or…

It is sad, but we should not confuse the death of a language with its culture. Spanish-speaking Yagans can still celebrate their culture and Yamana has given the world the word mamihlapinatapai.

Word Watch-

Mamihlapinatapai There have been several attempts to translate this Yamana word. For example: “A look shared by two people, each wishing that the other would initiate something that they both desire but which neither wants to begin.” Tower of Babel They wanted to build a tower that reached up to heaven. It was named Babel (Hebrew, bālal, to confuse) because God created a “confusion” of languages. Esperanto In English, “one who hopes”. Constructed in 1887 with simplified grammar to make it quicker to learn. There are around 100,000 Esperanto speakers. Cherokee A native language of the Cherokee people of North America.